Where informed patients make confident treatment decisions.
Save Your Thyroid with Jennifer Holkem
Save Your Thyroid with Jennifer Holkem
Thyroid nodules impact 70 percent of adults in their lifetime. The standard of care is surgical removal of half or all of the gland. But in recent years, nonsurgical treatment options have become available. Hi, my name is Jennifer Holkem and I advocate for fellow patients suffering with this very common condition. I sit down with patients and physicians and discuss life with thyroid nodules, the journey from diagnosis to treatment, and how to save your thyroid through nonsurgical advances in medicine.
Nov. 17, 2026

Nanopulse or RFA for Thyroid Nodules? A Surgeon Who Does Both Explains | Dr. David Goldenberg

What happens when your thyroid nodule is too close to the nerve that controls your voice?

For years, patients with nodules near the recurrent laryngeal nerve, trachea, or esophagus have been told they're not good candidates for RFA. Nanosecond pulsed field ablation (nsPFA, or "nanopulse") works without heat. That changes the conversation for some of those patients, but not all of them.

Dr. David Goldenberg is back, and this time we're going deep on nanopulse. Dr. Goldenberg is a professor and chair at Penn State Health, trained at Johns Hopkins, and the author of more than 275 peer-reviewed articles, 40 book chapters, and eight books. He leads Penn State's thyroid ablation training course and treats patients across the full spectrum: surgery, RFA, nanopulse, and active surveillance. He is also among the first physicians in the US to explore nanopulse for recurrent and metastatic thyroid cancer.

What happens when your thyroid nodule is too close to the nerve that controls your voice?

For years, patients with nodules near the recurrent laryngeal nerve, trachea, or esophagus have been told they're not good candidates for RFA. Nanosecond pulsed field ablation (nsPFA, or "nanopulse") works without heat. That changes the conversation for some of those patients, but not all of them.

Dr. David Goldenberg is back, and this time we're going deep on nanopulse. Dr. Goldenberg is a professor and chair at Penn State Health, trained at Johns Hopkins, and the author of more than 275 peer-reviewed articles, 40 book chapters, and eight books. He leads Penn State's thyroid ablation training course and treats patients across the full spectrum: surgery, RFA, nanopulse, and active surveillance. He is also among the first physicians in the US to explore nanopulse for recurrent and metastatic thyroid cancer.

"My job is not to sell them a procedure. My job is to determine which treatment makes the most sense."

Chapters

00:00 Introduction: what is nanopulse?

01:58 Welcome back, Dr. Goldenberg

02:02 Thermal vs. non-thermal ablation: how nanopulse works

04:50 Nodules near critical structures and the "danger triangle"

07:52 Does nanopulse complement or compete with RFA?

10:04 The 22-month durability data

11:46 Why annual follow-up matters

14:29 Post-ablation ultrasounds and TI-RADS misreads

17:11 What the nanopulse procedure is like: asleep vs. awake

21:25 Cystic vs. toxic nodules: where each technology shines

23:39 Treating cystic nodules: ethanol vs. RFA

25:13 Recovery after nanopulse vs. RFA

27:06 Traveling alone for treatment

29:02 From surgery referral to nanopulse (and the reverse)

33:19 Nanopulse for residual tissue after RFA

34:21 Where does the dead tissue go?

35:47 Nanopulse for recurrent and metastatic thyroid cancer

40:16 Who is NOT a candidate for ablation

42:13 How to choose: patient, disease, goal, anatomy, then technology

43:40 Availability and adoption in the US

45:07 Insurance coverage

46:51 Training for physicians

48:59 What patients should ask their physician

50:05 How to reach Dr. Goldenberg

🔗 Dr. David Goldenberg, Penn State Health:

Call 717-531-6822 and ask about minimally invasive thyroid treatment or thyroid ablation.

🎧 Watch next — Prof. Stefano Spiezia on the 22-month nsPFA durability data:

https://youtu.be/C149GI8iBnw

📌 Resources:

👉 Podcast: https://www.saveyourthyroidwithjen.com/

👉 Patient site & physician finder map: https://www.saveyourthyroid.org/

👉 Private FB group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/saveyourthyroidnonsurgical

👉 Patient Navigation: https://www.saveyourthyroidwithjen.com/patient-navigation-services/

💛 Support the channel:

PAYPAL 👉 https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/itsmejenagain

VENMO 👉 https://account.venmo.com/u/itsme_jenagain

🛍️ Affiliate links:

🌿 TOUPS AND CO: https://toupsandco.com/jen

🎙️ RIVERSIDE: https://www.riverside.fm/?via=itsmejenagain

🧴 VAN MAN: https://vanman.shop/?ref=itsmejenagain

💡 BON CHARGE: https://us.boncharge.com/?rfsn=7843863.50b9fa&shpxid=4137e8a5-8199-46cb-b71c-0f86d29324ff

⚠️ Disclaimer:

This podcast is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. No endorsement is given or implied for any specific product, treatment, or physician mentioned. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional regarding your individual medical needs.

🎵 Music licensed through Soundstripe:

KMYDMZEIZLMXB9GU

8HT4G3ITIDBS3VWT

JWH8TSVEQVPOWPMX


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:04,141
You're listening to Save Your Thyroid with
Jennifer Holkem the podcast where

2
00:00:04,141 --> 00:00:06,182
we explore thyroid sparing treatments,

3
00:00:06,562 --> 00:00:08,403
advocate for patient empowerment,

4
00:00:08,603 --> 00:00:12,405
and help you get back to the life you love
without unnecessary surgery.

5
00:00:12,691 --> 00:00:16,443
Every once in a while, a technology comes
along that genuinely changes

6
00:00:16,443 --> 00:00:17,443
the conversation.

7
00:00:17,541 --> 00:00:20,556
Radio frequency ablation did that for
thyroid patients

8
00:00:20,583 --> 00:00:23,039
who had been told surgery was their only
option.

9
00:00:23,180 --> 00:00:26,351
And now there's a new technology that's
beginning to do it again.

10
00:00:26,852 --> 00:00:30,733
called nanosecond pulsed field ablation or
nanopulse.

11
00:00:30,794 --> 00:00:35,750
I first encountered this technology at the
2023 American Thyroid Association meeting,

12
00:00:35,750 --> 00:00:38,082
where I was introduced to Pulse
Biosciences

13
00:00:38,125 --> 00:00:41,836
and heard the early data that honestly
left me a little speechless.

14
00:00:41,996 --> 00:00:44,357
Since then, I've followed the science
closely,

15
00:00:44,427 --> 00:00:48,689
interviewed Professor Stefano Spiezia
about the 22-month durability data.

16
00:00:48,829 --> 00:00:50,166
That he presented at NASIT

17
00:00:50,175 --> 00:00:53,118
and watch the conversation in the
physician community

18
00:00:53,233 --> 00:00:56,896
shift from curiosity to serious clinical
consideration.

19
00:00:57,047 --> 00:00:59,889
Unlike RFA, nanopulse doesn't use heat.

20
00:00:59,916 --> 00:01:05,269
It delivers ultra-short, precisely
controlled electrical pulses that disrupt

21
00:01:05,269 --> 00:01:07,333
the cell membrane of nodule tissue,

22
00:01:07,351 --> 00:01:08,772
triggering cell death

23
00:01:08,833 --> 00:01:10,266
without thermal damage.

24
00:01:10,394 --> 00:01:14,398
For nodules near critical structures where
heat carries additional risk.

25
00:01:14,545 --> 00:01:16,906
That distinction matters enormously.

26
00:01:16,932 --> 00:01:21,323
Today I'm going deep on this technology
with one of the most credentialed voices

27
00:01:21,323 --> 00:01:23,375
in the field of thyroid nodule management.

28
00:01:23,375 --> 00:01:27,291
Dr. David Goldenberg is a professor and
chair at Penn State Health,

29
00:01:27,291 --> 00:01:28,707
trained at Johns Hopkins,

30
00:01:28,755 --> 00:01:32,750
author of more than 275 peer-reviewed
journal articles,

31
00:01:32,789 --> 00:01:35,110
40 book chapters, and eight books.

32
00:01:35,296 --> 00:01:37,997
He leads Penn State's RFA training course

33
00:01:38,230 --> 00:01:40,636
and operates across the full thyroid

34
00:01:40,636 --> 00:01:41,094
spectrum,

35
00:01:41,094 --> 00:01:43,975
surgery, RFA, and now nanopulse.

36
00:01:44,004 --> 00:01:48,245
He's also among the first physicians in
the US to investigate nanopulse

37
00:01:48,291 --> 00:01:50,299
for thyroid cancer metastasis,

38
00:01:50,349 --> 00:01:54,260
work that is beginning to redefine what
non-surgical options look like

39
00:01:54,260 --> 00:01:56,651
for patients with persistent or recurrent
disease.

40
00:01:56,667 --> 00:01:58,420
Let's get into it. Dr. Goldenberg,

41
00:01:58,520 --> 00:01:59,540
welcome back to the show.

42
00:02:00,150 --> 00:02:01,354
Thank you, Jen, for having me.

43
00:02:01,354 --> 00:02:02,291
It's always a pleasure.

44
00:02:02,291 --> 00:02:06,913
same here. Well, I've been following
nanopulse technology for the last

45
00:02:06,913 --> 00:02:09,455
few years now. It's been really exciting.

46
00:02:09,455 --> 00:02:12,038
one of the things that really struck me
early on

47
00:02:12,194 --> 00:02:14,996
was the conversation in the physician
community.

48
00:02:14,996 --> 00:02:17,940
It wasn't about this being a new device.

49
00:02:17,940 --> 00:02:20,772
It was about a fundamentally different
mechanism.

50
00:02:20,772 --> 00:02:22,934
So let's start there. From where you sit,

51
00:02:23,014 --> 00:02:25,656
someone who's performing surgery.

52
00:02:25,836 --> 00:02:28,139
thermal and now non-thermal ablation.

53
00:02:28,760 --> 00:02:33,806
How would you characterize what makes
non-thermal ablation mechanistically

54
00:02:33,866 --> 00:02:40,334
different from RFA? And how is that
distinction really clinically significant

55
00:02:40,334 --> 00:02:44,289
rather than just being a marketing tool
for a technology?

56
00:02:44,877 --> 00:02:49,468
Well, you said it yourself. The
fundamental difference is that radio

57
00:02:49,468 --> 00:02:52,369
frequency ablation is a thermal
technology.

58
00:02:52,369 --> 00:02:58,611
It works by way of heat. And nanosecond
pulse field ablation is non thermal.

59
00:02:59,271 --> 00:03:04,353
With RFA, we generate heat to produce
coagulative necrosis.

60
00:03:05,413 --> 00:03:09,514
It's very effective. And over the years of
clinical experience,

61
00:03:10,095 --> 00:03:11,795
we've used it successfully. But

62
00:03:12,799 --> 00:03:15,800
Whenever you're using heat in the thyroid,

63
00:03:15,800 --> 00:03:21,023
you're thinking about how is that heat
going to travel non-target tissue.

64
00:03:21,803 --> 00:03:26,005
And we're operating millimeters away from
really important structures like

65
00:03:26,205 --> 00:03:29,807
the recurrent laryngeal nerve that gives
innervation to the voice box,

66
00:03:30,227 --> 00:03:32,908
the trachea, the esophagus, the carotid,

67
00:03:33,288 --> 00:03:38,981
and other really important structures with
nanosecond pulse field ablation.

68
00:03:39,705 --> 00:03:41,776
It takes a fundamentally different
approach.

69
00:03:41,776 --> 00:03:48,577
It delivers extremely short electrical
pulses that disrupt cellular homeostasis

70
00:03:48,577 --> 00:03:54,537
and initiates kind of a regular cell death
without really relying on thermal injury

71
00:03:54,537 --> 00:04:00,148
or or heat. So this is not really just a
technical distinction.

72
00:04:00,149 --> 00:04:03,960
potentially it changes the safety equation
when we're working.

73
00:04:04,111 --> 00:04:05,933
Close to these critical structures.

74
00:04:07,214 --> 00:04:11,223
So I wouldn't ever say that makes RFA
unsafe.

75
00:04:11,223 --> 00:04:16,767
That's just not true. RFA in experienced
hands is remarkably safe and remarkably

76
00:04:17,148 --> 00:04:20,611
effective. And I've used it for a couple
of years and I continue to use it,

77
00:04:21,052 --> 00:04:25,886
but it gives us another way of destroying
tissue that is clinically important.

78
00:04:27,296 --> 00:04:32,279
Yeah, I think that the mechanism of action
for nanopulse is so interesting.

79
00:04:32,279 --> 00:04:37,563
I mean, we're talking about triggering a
process that happens in our bodies

80
00:04:37,863 --> 00:04:41,666
all the time. You know, all of our cells
go through a life cycle.

81
00:04:42,206 --> 00:04:44,478
But for whatever reason, these nodules,

82
00:04:44,478 --> 00:04:46,289
they they need help with that.

83
00:04:46,289 --> 00:04:50,072
and so triggering this process for those
nodules will help them shrink.

84
00:04:50,072 --> 00:04:50,654
So

85
00:04:50,654 --> 00:04:53,326
Let's talk about the specific type of
nodule

86
00:04:53,356 --> 00:04:57,935
presentation where this type of
non-thermal approach as opposed

87
00:04:57,935 --> 00:05:00,876
to heat-based, would be more appropriate.

88
00:05:00,876 --> 00:05:04,417
And you know, you've already kind of
alluded to that with talking about those

89
00:05:04,437 --> 00:05:06,508
very important critical structures in the
neck.

90
00:05:06,798 --> 00:05:11,210
there are things that influence the
decision making that the patient

91
00:05:11,210 --> 00:05:14,142
and I make together about which technology
is right for them.

92
00:05:14,142 --> 00:05:20,746
So there are thyroid nodules where thermal
ablation is more risky than others.

93
00:05:21,367 --> 00:05:27,750
So the classic situation would be a nodule
which extends posteriorly backwards

94
00:05:27,750 --> 00:05:30,071
to the area that we call the danger
triangle.

95
00:05:30,641 --> 00:05:33,412
which is in between the the nodule,

96
00:05:33,412 --> 00:05:36,015
the trachea, and the recurrent laryngeal
nerve.

97
00:05:36,455 --> 00:05:41,899
With RFA, it doesn't necessarily mean that
we can't treat the patient,

98
00:05:42,060 --> 00:05:44,362
but it changes how we treat them.

99
00:05:44,962 --> 00:05:49,886
In those cases we would use hydro
dissection whereby we will inject dextrose

100
00:05:50,587 --> 00:05:51,828
to be a

101
00:05:52,204 --> 00:05:57,817
liquid buffer, if you will, in between the
critical structures and the thyroid

102
00:05:57,817 --> 00:06:01,509
nodule. We might use lower power
near-sensitive structures.

103
00:06:01,509 --> 00:06:06,872
Sometimes we may leave a small cuff or a
margin of untreated tissue on purpose.

104
00:06:06,872 --> 00:06:11,164
And that's where the non-thermal
technology nanopulse becomes really

105
00:06:11,164 --> 00:06:14,255
interesting. If I can effectively ablate
cells

106
00:06:14,611 --> 00:06:18,952
Without relying on heat, then
theoretically I can treat areas that

107
00:06:18,952 --> 00:06:22,673
I might be more cautious with the thermal
modality.

108
00:06:22,883 --> 00:06:27,045
it doesn't eliminate the need for
experience and meticulous technique,

109
00:06:27,045 --> 00:06:29,815
because you can certainly hurt someone
with all of these.

110
00:06:30,210 --> 00:06:31,680
you know, the recurrent nerve,

111
00:06:31,680 --> 00:06:34,351
still the recurrent nerve, but it gives us
a larger,

112
00:06:34,351 --> 00:06:37,022
what we like to call therapeutic window of
safety.

113
00:06:37,848 --> 00:06:40,419
Yeah. When you talk about the recurrent
laryngeal nerve,

114
00:06:40,419 --> 00:06:43,089
for the viewers who are not, familiar with
that term,

115
00:06:43,289 --> 00:06:47,700
that's the nerve that really is critically
important for your voice.

116
00:06:47,700 --> 00:06:50,771
And it also affects your ability to
swallow.

117
00:06:50,771 --> 00:06:56,273
And we've had some patients who had that
nerve affected by surgery,

118
00:06:56,733 --> 00:07:00,134
where they lost, you know, the ability to
really speak well.

119
00:07:00,134 --> 00:07:02,134
And we've also had some patients who lost,

120
00:07:02,455 --> 00:07:03,455
unfortunately,

121
00:07:03,747 --> 00:07:06,008
some function of that nerve from RFA.

122
00:07:06,189 --> 00:07:08,400
And those nodules that are, like you said,

123
00:07:08,400 --> 00:07:10,831
way back in the back that are close to
that nerve.

124
00:07:11,012 --> 00:07:13,674
sometimes patients who have nodules in
that location,

125
00:07:13,947 --> 00:07:17,229
you know, they're told they're not really
a good candidate for RFA.

126
00:07:17,670 --> 00:07:19,701
And so when I first learned about

127
00:07:20,513 --> 00:07:22,324
I thought this is so great because

128
00:07:22,324 --> 00:07:26,516
so many of these patients who have this
issue where the they have a nodule that's

129
00:07:26,516 --> 00:07:28,987
in the back of their thyroid that's close
to this nerve,

130
00:07:28,987 --> 00:07:31,068
they're not candidates for RFA,

131
00:07:31,068 --> 00:07:33,989
but now they may be candidates for
nanopulse.

132
00:07:34,030 --> 00:07:38,182
And I have another story I'll bring up
later on in the discussion that I think

133
00:07:38,182 --> 00:07:41,513
will be really interesting for the viewers
if they've not heard it already from

134
00:07:41,913 --> 00:07:46,515
one of our past thyroid cancer sessions we
did on the ThyCa

135
00:07:46,781 --> 00:07:48,653
Conference. I think it was last year.

136
00:07:48,653 --> 00:07:50,244
So tease that for the viewers,

137
00:07:50,244 --> 00:07:52,937
but stay tuned for that later on the
conversation.

138
00:07:52,937 --> 00:07:56,460
But I think that it's really interesting
how,

139
00:07:56,460 --> 00:08:02,536
as patients, we kind of think about this
in terms of how is it different from RFA?

140
00:08:02,536 --> 00:08:07,310
Because that was the first conversation we
had about non surgical treatments,

141
00:08:07,310 --> 00:08:10,793
right? that's kind of the bar we kind of
compare everything to.

142
00:08:11,590 --> 00:08:13,661
But some patients are even saying,

143
00:08:13,661 --> 00:08:14,972
and I hear this quite frequently,

144
00:08:15,390 --> 00:08:21,603
is nanopulse really going to complement
RFA or is it going to compete with it?

145
00:08:21,603 --> 00:08:25,175
Is it going to replace it? I personally
think there's a use case for both.

146
00:08:25,215 --> 00:08:26,536
I'd love to hear your take on that.

147
00:08:26,708 --> 00:08:31,812
Well, you said something interesting that
perhaps as a patient you don't

148
00:08:31,812 --> 00:08:35,985
see as surgeons, we see technology
advancing all the time.

149
00:08:35,985 --> 00:08:37,246
Um,

150
00:08:36,355 --> 00:08:37,286
Mm-hmm.

151
00:08:37,286 --> 00:08:40,809
it's something that we we rely on,

152
00:08:40,809 --> 00:08:44,092
on new technologies, new technique when it
comes to surgery.

153
00:08:44,092 --> 00:08:46,714
We have robotic surgery that we didn't
have.

154
00:08:47,014 --> 00:08:50,728
We have you know, all kinds of
technologies that weren't there 10 years

155
00:08:50,728 --> 00:08:52,379
ago. So right now.

156
00:08:53,461 --> 00:08:57,552
I see nanopulse as complementing
radiofrequency ablation.

157
00:08:57,892 --> 00:09:02,414
And I really would resist framing this as
RFA versus nanopulse.

158
00:09:02,614 --> 00:09:06,275
Exactly. RFA is an excellent evidence
based choice.

159
00:09:06,555 --> 00:09:10,016
We know its durability, its complications,

160
00:09:10,016 --> 00:09:13,637
its limitations, how to manage those
limitations.

161
00:09:13,637 --> 00:09:16,038
I treated many patients with RFA.

162
00:09:16,118 --> 00:09:18,511
I continue to believe strongly in it,

163
00:09:18,518 --> 00:09:20,379
and there are patients who I would say.

164
00:09:21,277 --> 00:09:23,709
You need RFA and not nanopulse.

165
00:09:24,129 --> 00:09:29,493
Nanopulse is another tool. and there may
be cases that over time

166
00:09:29,686 --> 00:09:33,216
one clearly performs better than the
other.

167
00:09:33,216 --> 00:09:38,130
the future of thyroid ablation isn't going
to be one technology winning

168
00:09:38,130 --> 00:09:43,533
and one losing. It's going to be
physicians understanding all of these

169
00:09:43,533 --> 00:09:45,605
technologies well enough to help.

170
00:09:45,883 --> 00:09:48,275
Make the right selection together with the
patient,

171
00:09:48,576 --> 00:09:52,430
what is right for you, what is right for
someone else.

172
00:09:53,040 --> 00:09:54,842
Very well said. I couldn't agree more.

173
00:09:54,842 --> 00:09:59,997
I think it's very important to just keep
that perspective of we're talking about

174
00:09:59,997 --> 00:10:04,498
tools in the toolbox. We're not talking
about one technology to rule them all.

175
00:10:04,498 --> 00:10:08,596
So I I love that perspective. and you
know,

176
00:10:08,596 --> 00:10:12,959
going back to the comparison to RFA is so
many people are always

177
00:10:13,331 --> 00:10:17,073
concerned about the long-term success of
these technologies.

178
00:10:17,073 --> 00:10:21,495
And so one question that we've heard from
skeptics is is this going to last?

179
00:10:21,495 --> 00:10:25,757
Is the durability of the result of
nanopulse actually there?

180
00:10:25,976 --> 00:10:32,769
And we saw that data, the 22 month data
from the study that's been

181
00:10:32,769 --> 00:10:34,894
done on this presented at the NASIT
meeting.

182
00:10:34,894 --> 00:10:37,101
Would you like to talk us through that?

183
00:10:37,321 --> 00:10:38,321
Sure.

184
00:10:38,601 --> 00:10:40,563
Your question about durability is
important.

185
00:10:41,443 --> 00:10:43,145
It's one of the most important questions.

186
00:10:43,145 --> 00:10:47,208
The initial clinical results are very
encouraging.

187
00:10:47,208 --> 00:10:50,930
We've seen substantial volume reduction in
the treatment of benign nodules

188
00:10:50,930 --> 00:10:55,394
and longer-term follow-up that was
presented by Professor Spiezia.

189
00:10:55,694 --> 00:10:58,977
It's extended approximately from 15 to 22
months.

190
00:10:58,977 --> 00:11:02,259
I neither me nor you can make time move
faster than it is.

191
00:11:02,694 --> 00:11:03,398
Yeah.

192
00:11:03,398 --> 00:11:08,119
So unfortunately, and I I believe that you
can't get more impatient than a surgeon.

193
00:11:08,129 --> 00:11:10,490
I would say we were really gonna have to
wait to see.

194
00:11:10,750 --> 00:11:12,771
everyone's know is the tissue really gone?

195
00:11:12,951 --> 00:11:17,553
Did it disappear? will the reduction
persist if we don't use heat?

196
00:11:17,793 --> 00:11:23,525
the emerging data says yeah. But we have
to be scientifically disciplined here.

197
00:11:24,245 --> 00:11:30,277
RFA has years more of follow-up regarding
regarding a larger number of patients.

198
00:11:30,277 --> 00:11:32,377
And that we have to be fair about that.

199
00:11:32,377 --> 00:11:35,477
Nanopulse just doesn't have the depth of
evidence yet.

200
00:11:35,477 --> 00:11:40,378
I would describe the durability as very
encouraging but still maturing.

201
00:11:41,533 --> 00:11:46,354
and that's why ongoing prospective studies
and longer follow up are so important.

202
00:11:46,694 --> 00:11:49,755
I will add that when I do either RFA.

203
00:11:50,635 --> 00:11:53,038
Or nanopulse on all of my patients,

204
00:11:53,639 --> 00:11:58,904
I get a commitment from them that they're
willing to come in once a year after

205
00:11:58,904 --> 00:12:03,209
everything's said and done and just get an
ultrasound to show me how things are.

206
00:12:03,410 --> 00:12:06,432
And that's how I hope to get long-term
data.

207
00:12:06,432 --> 00:12:09,345
And I will tell you, I've not had one
patient who has not been thrilled

208
00:12:09,345 --> 00:12:10,345
to do that.

209
00:12:10,346 --> 00:12:12,568
And that's very important. I'm glad you
brought that up.

210
00:12:12,671 --> 00:12:14,032
It's something that we always

211
00:12:14,178 --> 00:12:16,239
counsel patients in the community and tell
them,

212
00:12:16,840 --> 00:12:19,582
you are not just getting rid of this
nodule,

213
00:12:19,642 --> 00:12:20,963
no matter how you're treating it.

214
00:12:21,103 --> 00:12:25,357
You are going to be on the hook for this
continued follow-up for the rest of your

215
00:12:25,357 --> 00:12:26,808
life. And that's very important.

216
00:12:27,088 --> 00:12:30,451
Otherwise, how are you going to know if
you have actually achieved success?

217
00:12:30,972 --> 00:12:32,683
Right. So I always tell patients,

218
00:12:32,703 --> 00:12:35,225
if you travel for treatment, make sure you
have.

219
00:12:36,213 --> 00:12:38,895
Access to someone who can follow up with
you locally.

220
00:12:38,895 --> 00:12:42,767
If you can't make it happen where you can
get to see your doctor,

221
00:12:42,767 --> 00:12:45,183
you know, every year or so. it's hard.

222
00:12:45,463 --> 00:12:48,085
I acknowledge that. I acknowledge that
it's expensive.

223
00:12:48,466 --> 00:12:50,447
most people are still traveling for
treatment.

224
00:12:50,507 --> 00:12:53,128
Unfortunately, that's just how it is
today.

225
00:12:53,128 --> 00:12:55,670
But eventually we'll get there.

226
00:12:55,670 --> 00:12:59,305
I I really look forward to the day when
this is available in every,

227
00:12:59,305 --> 00:13:00,185
you know.

228
00:13:00,185 --> 00:13:01,935
In every state, in every major,

229
00:13:01,945 --> 00:13:03,865
metropolitan area in the in the country.

230
00:13:03,865 --> 00:13:05,566
And one thing that's really exciting,

231
00:13:05,706 --> 00:13:08,000
I'll just give a plug for our website real
quick.

232
00:13:08,075 --> 00:13:09,635
Our website, saveyourthyroid.org,

233
00:13:09,635 --> 00:13:11,416
where you can find a physician near you.

234
00:13:11,696 --> 00:13:14,269
Go to at the top where it says find a
physician.

235
00:13:14,269 --> 00:13:20,482
We actually now have a map view where you
can see on a map where the physicians

236
00:13:20,482 --> 00:13:22,843
are nearest your geographic area.

237
00:13:23,163 --> 00:13:25,705
it's a lot easier for you to take in that
information,

238
00:13:25,705 --> 00:13:27,346
I think, than just looking at a
spreadsheet.

239
00:13:27,346 --> 00:13:32,189
But you can go on that spreadsheet or on
that website and see,

240
00:13:32,410 --> 00:13:34,251
you know, well, I'm gonna go see Dr.

241
00:13:34,251 --> 00:13:37,934
Goldenberg for my treatment, but if I
can't make it to see him next year

242
00:13:37,934 --> 00:13:41,066
for my ultrasound, maybe I could see
someone a little closer and then they

243
00:13:41,066 --> 00:13:43,978
can collaborate with one another on my on
my follow up.

244
00:13:43,978 --> 00:13:48,460
I don't know if that's as as desirable to
you on your end,

245
00:13:48,480 --> 00:13:49,236
but

246
00:13:49,236 --> 00:13:51,348
can we make that work for for patients?

247
00:13:51,348 --> 00:13:55,562
I certainly hope that, we're in a state
now where we can collaborate more

248
00:13:55,562 --> 00:13:59,705
and and work together and do what's what's
gonna help the most number of people.

249
00:13:59,757 --> 00:14:03,230
it's important point. And if you allow me
to jump in on that,

250
00:14:03,230 --> 00:14:09,304
absolutely patients in in central
Pennsylvania at the Penn State Health,

251
00:14:09,785 --> 00:14:12,467
but I hold, a New York and a Maryland
license.

252
00:14:12,467 --> 00:14:15,709
And you know, people a lot of people come
to me from out of state because

253
00:14:15,709 --> 00:14:18,851
I'm one of the only physicians in the area
providing this service.

254
00:14:19,432 --> 00:14:24,695
And, you know, I keep those licenses so I
so I can do telehealth visits with

255
00:14:24,695 --> 00:14:25,695
patients.

256
00:14:25,850 --> 00:14:28,541
Who are in upstate New York or Maryland.

257
00:14:29,622 --> 00:14:33,644
The issue is that the follow-up is done by
ultrasound.

258
00:14:33,972 --> 00:14:34,764
Right.

259
00:14:34,764 --> 00:14:39,305
And one of the problems we're seeing is
the fact that the ultrasonographers

260
00:14:39,825 --> 00:14:45,508
who are not familiar with the technology
are having a hard time interpreting what

261
00:14:45,508 --> 00:14:46,370
they see.

262
00:14:46,370 --> 00:14:51,742
And the the size of the nodule and the
volume reduction rate are not the same

263
00:14:51,742 --> 00:14:52,332
thing.

264
00:14:52,332 --> 00:14:57,664
And using a TIRAD score after someone has
been ablated,

265
00:14:58,004 --> 00:15:01,825
well, TIRAD is only for an untreated
nodule.

266
00:15:01,825 --> 00:15:03,005
And you say, okay,

267
00:15:03,238 --> 00:15:06,739
person goes and gets an ultrasound in a
place that they're not used to it,

268
00:15:07,259 --> 00:15:09,159
and their ultrasonographer is going,

269
00:15:09,329 --> 00:15:10,960
my God, look at all these changes,

270
00:15:10,960 --> 00:15:12,780
which were caused by ablation.

271
00:15:13,100 --> 00:15:15,521
And he upgrades the TIRAD score,

272
00:15:15,521 --> 00:15:18,102
which is inappropriate. Patient gets
scared.

273
00:15:18,242 --> 00:15:18,764
So

274
00:15:18,764 --> 00:15:22,015
It's not just about having a clinician
close by,

275
00:15:22,214 --> 00:15:25,657
but it's also about having
ultrasonographers,

276
00:15:25,897 --> 00:15:30,429
if it's close to your home, who understand
what happened and know how to interpret

277
00:15:30,429 --> 00:15:33,981
it in the context. So I know I'm
digressing a little bit from what we're

278
00:15:33,981 --> 00:15:36,542
talking to about, but it is a very
important.

279
00:15:37,210 --> 00:15:40,473
No, 100% agree, and and it's very
important.

280
00:15:40,473 --> 00:15:45,697
the reason why I mention our site and our
list is because those physicians on that

281
00:15:45,697 --> 00:15:49,120
list are all familiar with different types
of ablation.

282
00:15:49,120 --> 00:15:52,242
They do it themselves, they all do their
own ultrasounds,

283
00:15:52,643 --> 00:15:56,527
and they're gonna understand better what
they're looking at than someone who's

284
00:15:56,527 --> 00:16:01,321
not familiar, and a hundred percent agree
the TIRAD scoring that absolutely

285
00:16:01,321 --> 00:16:03,263
infuriates me when a patient

286
00:16:03,457 --> 00:16:06,140
who's had an ablation they're thrilled
about the results,

287
00:16:06,181 --> 00:16:10,045
then they go to a local imaging center and
they come back to the community screaming,

288
00:16:10,346 --> 00:16:13,640
I'm I I I've been told that I have a
TIRADS five nodule.

289
00:16:13,640 --> 00:16:17,415
What what is going on here? And I tell
them disregard.

290
00:16:17,796 --> 00:16:21,079
Just disregard. It's not they don't know
what they're looking at.

291
00:16:21,223 --> 00:16:23,165
We're publishing a couple of studies now,

292
00:16:23,165 --> 00:16:25,868
together with radiology to try and help
address that,

293
00:16:26,168 --> 00:16:31,139
to help educate our colleagues in
radiology so that they're you know better

294
00:16:31,139 --> 00:16:35,403
they're accustomed to these changes and
how to measure them so that exactly that

295
00:16:35,403 --> 00:16:36,694
doesn't happen. But all right,

296
00:16:36,694 --> 00:16:37,039
yeah.

297
00:16:37,039 --> 00:16:38,400
That's wonderful. I'm glad to hear that.

298
00:17:11,358 --> 00:17:15,431
Well, I want to get into what this looks
like in practice because I think

299
00:17:15,431 --> 00:17:19,774
one of the things that helps patients most
understand it is not just thinking about

300
00:17:19,774 --> 00:17:22,606
the science, but actually the experience
of the procedure.

301
00:17:22,906 --> 00:17:24,542
And now you've done enough of these,

302
00:17:24,542 --> 00:17:26,228
you can certainly speak to that directly.

303
00:17:26,228 --> 00:17:30,791
So walk us through what's procedurally
similar to RFA,

304
00:17:31,051 --> 00:17:32,832
what's genuinely different.

305
00:17:32,832 --> 00:17:36,309
both from your perspective and the
patient's perspective of the nanopulse

306
00:17:36,309 --> 00:17:37,111
procedure.

307
00:17:37,111 --> 00:17:38,913
if you are looking from the outside in,

308
00:17:38,913 --> 00:17:42,616
it it's very similar. The procedure looks
very similar.

309
00:17:42,616 --> 00:17:44,437
It's an ultrasound guided procedure.

310
00:17:44,437 --> 00:17:48,471
we identify the nodule, we map out
critical structures,

311
00:17:48,471 --> 00:17:52,865
we make sure we can reach and then we
place the electrode through the skin after

312
00:17:52,945 --> 00:17:56,464
r local and regional anesthesia and

313
00:17:56,832 --> 00:17:58,853
We do the same the same procedure over.

314
00:17:58,853 --> 00:18:00,573
If you look at the inside it looks
identical.

315
00:18:00,573 --> 00:18:02,153
what's different is first of all,

316
00:18:02,153 --> 00:18:04,434
for nanopulse, most of my patients are
asleep,

317
00:18:04,434 --> 00:18:06,714
and for RFA, most of my patients are
awake,

318
00:18:06,995 --> 00:18:12,326
with exceptions. But the energy delivery
itself is different.

319
00:18:12,326 --> 00:18:17,018
You know, with RFA, we're I'm continually
thinking about the heat,

320
00:18:17,018 --> 00:18:18,858
the power settings, the impedance,

321
00:18:19,178 --> 00:18:20,739
the moving shot technique.

322
00:18:21,289 --> 00:18:25,820
am i causing indirect thermal injury am i
protecting the surrounding structures

323
00:18:25,985 --> 00:18:31,730
nanopulse is these very brief electrical
pulse sequence and the treatment cycles

324
00:18:31,910 --> 00:18:37,832
are short and i progressively reposition
the electrode to create overlapping areas

325
00:18:37,832 --> 00:18:41,683
because overlapping area you can't really
over ablate that and

326
00:18:42,821 --> 00:18:47,042
I don't see the changes with my eyes as
readily.

327
00:18:47,883 --> 00:18:50,523
But these are little things that you may
not notice.

328
00:18:50,523 --> 00:18:53,244
nanopulse causes some muscle twitching,

329
00:18:53,884 --> 00:18:55,714
which is why my patients are asleep,

330
00:18:55,714 --> 00:18:57,165
because although it's not painful,

331
00:18:57,365 --> 00:18:59,764
people find it disconcerting. so that you
know,

332
00:18:59,765 --> 00:19:03,837
If you are skilled at interventional
thyroidology,

333
00:19:03,837 --> 00:19:06,118
those skills transfer very well.

334
00:19:06,128 --> 00:19:10,239
and it will look identical. The only thing
that's different is the I guess

335
00:19:10,239 --> 00:19:11,239
the technology.

336
00:19:11,946 --> 00:19:14,408
Yeah. And I'm glad you mentioned that
about,

337
00:19:14,408 --> 00:19:16,760
RFA, they're awake and nanopulse,

338
00:19:16,760 --> 00:19:18,611
they're asleep. generally speaking,

339
00:19:18,631 --> 00:19:22,223
we do have patients who ask, why on earth
would you want to be awake during

340
00:19:22,223 --> 00:19:24,694
a procedure like RFA? And we tell them,

341
00:19:24,694 --> 00:19:26,755
just like you were talking about with the
heat.

342
00:19:27,195 --> 00:19:31,438
We want to make sure that the heat is not
getting too close to that laryngeal nerve.

343
00:19:31,438 --> 00:19:34,380
And so if you are able to speak during the
procedure.

344
00:19:35,040 --> 00:19:36,381
Then guess what? We're doing well.

345
00:19:36,381 --> 00:19:40,903
that's not necessary with the nanopulse
because there's no heat to damage

346
00:19:40,903 --> 00:19:45,705
the nerve. And I've been able to observe
one nanopulse procedure.

347
00:19:45,826 --> 00:19:49,384
And you're right, it from the perspective
of onlookers,

348
00:19:49,864 --> 00:19:51,805
it looks pretty much identical.

349
00:19:52,455 --> 00:19:53,956
you mentioned the treatment cycles,

350
00:19:53,956 --> 00:19:57,738
you know, there's I believe it's eight
seconds for a treatment cycle,

351
00:19:57,738 --> 00:19:59,348
and then you reposition the probe.

352
00:19:59,348 --> 00:20:00,348
And but

353
00:20:00,430 --> 00:20:02,151
Essentially it looks identical,

354
00:20:02,151 --> 00:20:07,103
but the patient is asleep. those twitching
sensations that the patient is having,

355
00:20:07,103 --> 00:20:09,835
I can see how now that I've observed it,

356
00:20:09,835 --> 00:20:13,787
I can see how that would maybe make a
patient feel a little odd or maybe

357
00:20:13,787 --> 00:20:17,879
a little nervous. And so what I've been
told about the sedation is that

358
00:20:17,879 --> 00:20:21,341
it is similar to sedation you have with
the colonoscopy,

359
00:20:21,741 --> 00:20:24,653
that it causes you to just take a nice
little nap.

360
00:20:24,857 --> 00:20:26,810
And you don't really remember anything.

361
00:20:26,810 --> 00:20:32,060
And so that's really from my perspective
as a patient observing the procedure,

362
00:20:32,521 --> 00:20:34,244
really the the main difference.

363
00:20:34,860 --> 00:20:39,822
this affords us the opportunity to ex to
offer patients more variety.

364
00:20:40,562 --> 00:20:43,253
I have patients who say, Why would you
want to be awake for this?

365
00:20:43,253 --> 00:20:45,824
And I have patients who say, Why would you
want to be asleep for this?

366
00:20:45,824 --> 00:20:51,265
And we try and accommodate whatever the
patient wants as long as they understand

367
00:20:51,265 --> 00:20:54,716
the expectations. It happens rarely,

368
00:20:54,716 --> 00:20:58,087
but when I was doing RFA, where I've had
patients who after two seconds says,

369
00:20:58,327 --> 00:21:00,078
I'm not doing this. And they got up and
they said,

370
00:21:00,078 --> 00:21:01,036
This is not for me.

371
00:21:01,036 --> 00:21:04,378
Maybe one out of many, many I've done or
two,

372
00:21:04,638 --> 00:21:07,199
and that's okay. And it wasn't because of
pain.

373
00:21:07,559 --> 00:21:09,180
It's more about when you're awake,

374
00:21:09,620 --> 00:21:14,002
it is anxiety provoking because I'm
sitting behind the patient.

375
00:21:14,002 --> 00:21:16,764
I'm with my hands towards their neck,

376
00:21:17,164 --> 00:21:20,475
very close to them. And everyone is a
little bit different,

377
00:21:20,475 --> 00:21:24,137
but you know, we are usually we're able to
accommodate what it is,

378
00:21:24,137 --> 00:21:25,137
whatever the patient wants.

379
00:21:25,523 --> 00:21:27,024
we've talked about this a little bit,

380
00:21:27,024 --> 00:21:28,484
but I want to touch on it some more.

381
00:21:28,486 --> 00:21:31,879
Is the topic of the nodules
characteristics,

382
00:21:31,879 --> 00:21:37,232
primarily the location, but also are there
characteristics of a nodule,

383
00:21:37,232 --> 00:21:40,255
the size, the composition, the
vascularity?

384
00:21:41,015 --> 00:21:47,006
where you found nanopulse consistently
outperforms RFA or outperforms your

385
00:21:47,006 --> 00:21:51,755
expectations, or where it's been maybe
more humbling than you anticipated.

386
00:21:53,271 --> 00:21:59,382
Absolutely. And I've been doing nanopulse
for almost a year now and I've been doing

387
00:21:59,382 --> 00:22:01,194
RFA for more than six years.

388
00:22:01,194 --> 00:22:06,638
still, I would say that for a purely
cystic nodule or a nodule where

389
00:22:06,744 --> 00:22:10,046
the the vast majority of it is cystic,

390
00:22:10,607 --> 00:22:14,450
I still think that thermal ablation is
king.

391
00:22:14,555 --> 00:22:17,407
on the other hand, for toxic nodules,

392
00:22:17,407 --> 00:22:20,359
meaning nodules that are secreting thyroid
hormone,

393
00:22:20,359 --> 00:22:24,902
I have been less than enthused with radio
frequency ablation.

394
00:22:25,223 --> 00:22:27,844
And I'm thrilled with nanopulse,

395
00:22:28,185 --> 00:22:32,147
giving me giving the patient better
results and quicker results.

396
00:22:32,187 --> 00:22:34,868
and sometimes you have no choice but to
say,

397
00:22:34,868 --> 00:22:35,644
well.

398
00:22:35,644 --> 00:22:37,555
this person has a small cystic portion,

399
00:22:37,555 --> 00:22:43,266
but a large solid portion. I'm going to do
the nodule with nanopulse,

400
00:22:43,606 --> 00:22:46,387
and then you see that the cystic portion
fails.

401
00:22:47,011 --> 00:22:50,222
So, you know, we're all learning this
together.

402
00:22:50,222 --> 00:22:52,733
This is a conversation with a patient.

403
00:22:52,733 --> 00:22:57,695
nanopulse gives us substantial volume
reduction quickly.

404
00:22:58,259 --> 00:23:00,562
radio frequency ablasion does the same.

405
00:23:00,562 --> 00:23:03,794
It just takes a little bit longer,

406
00:23:03,794 --> 00:23:04,654
I would say.

407
00:23:04,654 --> 00:23:11,413
I I think it would be a mistake to say
with any new technology that only this

408
00:23:11,413 --> 00:23:14,174
works for this type and only this works
for the other type.

409
00:23:14,415 --> 00:23:17,507
That's where you have you need to have
some judgment.

410
00:23:17,507 --> 00:23:22,420
And to be honest, I am still learning the
nuances.

411
00:23:23,521 --> 00:23:26,943
There's a handful of us doing this
technology in the United States at this

412
00:23:26,943 --> 00:23:29,345
time. We mostly know each other.

413
00:23:29,889 --> 00:23:31,750
When we get together, we talk about it.

414
00:23:31,911 --> 00:23:36,014
And I think I we would say that we all are
learning the nuances.

415
00:23:36,834 --> 00:23:38,936
But you know, that's what makes it
exciting.

416
00:23:39,760 --> 00:23:43,434
Yeah, totally. I have a follow-up question
about the cystic nodules.

417
00:23:43,434 --> 00:23:47,809
Sure. If you've got a nodule that's got a
large cystic component,

418
00:23:47,809 --> 00:23:51,773
is it possible to treat the cystic
component with ethanol and then ablate

419
00:23:51,773 --> 00:23:53,435
the rest with nanopulse

420
00:23:53,785 --> 00:23:55,966
Sure, it's possible. I've not done that.

421
00:23:55,966 --> 00:23:58,436
I do not I do not do ethanol ablations.

422
00:23:58,776 --> 00:24:04,639
I have been very successful with straight
garden variety RFA.

423
00:24:04,639 --> 00:24:10,831
I collapse the majority of the cyst over
the the probe.

424
00:24:10,831 --> 00:24:12,742
So I'll place the probe in the cyst,

425
00:24:13,182 --> 00:24:14,463
I'll place a needle.

426
00:24:15,161 --> 00:24:21,443
Right next to it parallel. I deflate the
vast majority of the cyst and pull

427
00:24:21,443 --> 00:24:25,525
out the draining needle. And then I have a
collapsed cyst

428
00:24:25,628 --> 00:24:31,483
that is fit over my probe. I will then
ablate the collapsed walls

429
00:24:32,144 --> 00:24:33,945
of the cyst so they no longer.

430
00:24:34,389 --> 00:24:37,447
will secrete fluid. And that's actually
been really successful,

431
00:24:37,447 --> 00:24:41,444
but I can't speak to to ethanol because
it's not a technology I've ever done.

432
00:24:41,654 --> 00:24:43,095
Glad you explained that actually,

433
00:24:43,095 --> 00:24:47,239
because I've I've heard there are a lot of
doctors out there who don't like

434
00:24:47,239 --> 00:24:50,361
to use ethanol, and that's their preferred
technique for that.

435
00:24:50,361 --> 00:24:53,263
unfortunately, ethanol has become very
expensive.

436
00:24:53,604 --> 00:24:59,657
So it can be actually prohibitively
expensive to buy it for what should have

437
00:24:59,657 --> 00:25:03,290
been actually a much cheaper procedure
because it's you know it's done

438
00:25:03,290 --> 00:25:07,503
in the office, it's done without even any
anesthesia at all.

439
00:25:07,503 --> 00:25:09,235
It's just a quick, you know, thing.

440
00:25:09,811 --> 00:25:13,242
But unfortunately the cost has just become
kind of ridiculous.

441
00:25:13,242 --> 00:25:18,025
So well, let's go back, let's hit one more
topic on the comparison between

442
00:25:18,085 --> 00:25:21,727
RFA and nanopulse, which is the patient's
recovery process.

443
00:25:21,727 --> 00:25:25,729
you've already mentioned that the
shrinking of the nodule happens quite

444
00:25:25,729 --> 00:25:27,850
rapidly, faster than with RFA.

445
00:25:28,210 --> 00:25:33,854
What is the difference then with their
recovery trajectory compared to

446
00:25:33,986 --> 00:25:35,824
what they would experience post RFA.

447
00:25:36,551 --> 00:25:40,493
generally the recovery is favorable and
identical.

448
00:25:40,974 --> 00:25:44,435
these are fundamentally minimally invasive
procedures.

449
00:25:44,435 --> 00:25:46,997
whether they do it awake or asleep,

450
00:25:47,217 --> 00:25:48,948
the patient has to have a driver with
them.

451
00:25:48,978 --> 00:25:52,620
I have them put ice on the neck for twenty
four hours.

452
00:25:52,840 --> 00:25:57,533
Pain is if there is any, is controlled
with Tylenol and ibuprofen.

453
00:25:58,551 --> 00:26:01,513
and they return to normal activity 24
hours later.

454
00:26:02,713 --> 00:26:04,393
And that doesn't matter which one.

455
00:26:05,234 --> 00:26:07,614
Some will have discomfort or swelling.

456
00:26:08,155 --> 00:26:13,426
I'm putting a probe in and out and in and
out of the thyroid gland,

457
00:26:13,426 --> 00:26:17,237
and you know, there's going to be some
there's going to be a little

458
00:26:17,237 --> 00:26:20,179
bit of swelling there. but it's not a
surgical incision.

459
00:26:20,793 --> 00:26:27,118
I have found that they ooze from their
little holes a little bit less

460
00:26:27,579 --> 00:26:33,102
in the short term with RFA. And I suspect
that's because there's it's a thermal

461
00:26:33,403 --> 00:26:37,666
device or probably cauterizes some of
those smaller skin vessels,

462
00:26:37,806 --> 00:26:41,560
but it's never been an issue. the
counseling is exactly the same.

463
00:26:42,220 --> 00:26:45,916
we check up on them the next day or two to
see how they're doing.

464
00:26:46,410 --> 00:26:50,076
yeah, I I would say that the recovery is
identical and and easy.

465
00:26:51,053 --> 00:26:53,194
Yeah. having RFA is really

466
00:26:53,362 --> 00:26:54,973
when you compare it to having surgery.

467
00:26:54,973 --> 00:26:56,433
Now I've never had thyroid surgery,

468
00:26:56,433 --> 00:27:01,876
but I've had other surgeries. having RFA
is not anything like recovering from

469
00:27:01,876 --> 00:27:06,648
a surgery. So you know, that's one of the
best things about these minimally invasive

470
00:27:06,648 --> 00:27:10,709
procedures. I do have a follow-up question
one of my most recent patient consults

471
00:27:11,129 --> 00:27:14,170
was a patient who's actually not located
in the United States.

472
00:27:14,850 --> 00:27:17,911
She's very interested in coming to the US
for treatment.

473
00:27:18,091 --> 00:27:21,072
She wants specifically nanopulse.

474
00:27:21,072 --> 00:27:26,523
And she was talking with me about trying
to keep her costs down because it is going

475
00:27:26,523 --> 00:27:29,714
to be quite expensive for her to travel
and also pay for her procedure.

476
00:27:30,154 --> 00:27:32,175
And so she was considering coming alone.

477
00:27:32,935 --> 00:27:36,530
And she wanted to know: is that something
that I could do?

478
00:27:36,796 --> 00:27:38,606
Would it be safe? What do you think?

479
00:27:38,606 --> 00:27:42,768
And what I told her was, I would
definitely choose wherever

480
00:27:42,768 --> 00:27:43,888
you go for treatment.

481
00:27:44,412 --> 00:27:46,663
To be in a city where you could easily,

482
00:27:46,802 --> 00:27:50,563
get an Uber from wherever you're being
treated back to your hotel.

483
00:27:50,801 --> 00:27:55,344
I would plan to stay maybe two or three
days before trying to get on a plane

484
00:27:55,344 --> 00:27:57,665
and travel alone all the way back to where
you live.

485
00:27:57,885 --> 00:27:59,075
what are your thoughts on that,

486
00:27:59,075 --> 00:28:02,987
Dr. Goldenberg? Because I think that I'm
kind of just projecting some

487
00:28:02,987 --> 00:28:07,048
of my own personal experience to RFA onto
the situation.

488
00:28:07,348 --> 00:28:11,119
And I'd like to know kind of if that is an
accurate assessment.

489
00:28:11,299 --> 00:28:13,005
What would what would you say to that
patient?

490
00:28:13,883 --> 00:28:17,526
Yeah, I think you're right. I think if
there w if if someone's traveling from

491
00:28:17,526 --> 00:28:21,887
abroad and they don't have anyone to
escort them,

492
00:28:21,887 --> 00:28:24,379
that's usually something I think we can
probably work out.

493
00:28:24,430 --> 00:28:27,717
I can talk about this is it's its own
show,

494
00:28:27,773 --> 00:28:31,695
the billing coding and insurance support.

495
00:28:32,019 --> 00:28:33,980
or non-support of these procedures.

496
00:28:33,980 --> 00:28:36,383
That is its own show whenever you get
around to it.

497
00:28:36,383 --> 00:28:39,405
And and it's a moving target, to be
perfectly honest.

498
00:28:39,405 --> 00:28:42,648
yeah, I don't think that that would be
something that would be insurmountable.

499
00:28:42,769 --> 00:28:45,431
I really don't I don't know that that's
doable.

500
00:28:45,931 --> 00:28:50,175
Take a hotel, some hospitals have a hotel
in the hospital itself,

501
00:28:50,396 --> 00:28:51,867
others have it across the street.

502
00:28:52,357 --> 00:28:56,807
Usually big medical centers like ours are
no close proximity to a lot of hotels.

503
00:28:56,887 --> 00:28:58,410
you know, people do come from abroad.

504
00:28:58,410 --> 00:29:00,084
It's not it's not unheard of.

505
00:29:00,538 --> 00:29:02,249
Yeah, I definitely think it's doable.

506
00:29:02,249 --> 00:29:06,750
So all right. Well, I know from my own
patient navigation work,

507
00:29:06,750 --> 00:29:07,921
like we were just talking about,

508
00:29:08,061 --> 00:29:12,583
one of the most common situations that I
see is that a patient's told that they're

509
00:29:12,583 --> 00:29:15,665
not a candidate for RFA because of the
nodule's location,

510
00:29:16,385 --> 00:29:17,806
or like we were just talking about,

511
00:29:17,806 --> 00:29:19,327
because of a cystic component,

512
00:29:19,327 --> 00:29:21,968
or maybe it's just a challenging nodule.

513
00:29:22,428 --> 00:29:26,190
And so I'm really curious to talk more
about how nanopulse is changing that

514
00:29:26,190 --> 00:29:27,190
equation. So

515
00:29:28,131 --> 00:29:33,446
Have you ever had a patient who would have
gone straight to surgery in the past,

516
00:29:33,446 --> 00:29:36,339
but now you're willing to perform
nanopulse on them?

517
00:29:36,650 --> 00:29:38,588
I've had three patients like that this
morning.

518
00:29:39,505 --> 00:29:40,505
What?

519
00:29:40,508 --> 00:29:45,600
I had two patients who came in thinking
they need surgery and they're going

520
00:29:45,600 --> 00:29:50,773
to get nano pulse ablation. And I had one
patient who came for ablation who is going

521
00:29:50,773 --> 00:29:54,445
to be leaving with surgery because that's
the right thing to do.

522
00:29:54,445 --> 00:30:01,059
So one of the great things about having a
thyroid practice

523
00:30:01,259 --> 00:30:04,360
that can offer all three options,

524
00:30:04,360 --> 00:30:07,182
and the three options are surgery.

525
00:30:07,936 --> 00:30:14,810
ablation observation observation is a a
treatment option as well okay call

526
00:30:14,810 --> 00:30:19,473
it active surveillance call it whatever
you want but it is it is an option we'll

527
00:30:18,519 --> 00:30:19,473
Absolutely.

528
00:30:19,473 --> 00:30:23,230
take that so i have a discussion with each
one of the patients like i said

529
00:30:23,230 --> 00:30:27,707
i had three this morning who the what what
they came in for was not what they left

530
00:30:27,707 --> 00:30:29,298
with actually two of them

531
00:30:29,834 --> 00:30:34,046
were sent for surgery and I said I have
something else to offer you.

532
00:30:34,046 --> 00:30:36,427
And, you know, I had a long talk,

533
00:30:36,427 --> 00:30:37,847
gave them some written material,

534
00:30:38,807 --> 00:30:41,788
told them they can have surgery and and if
they want to.

535
00:30:41,788 --> 00:30:44,689
And it's part of it has to do with the
patient's anatomy.

536
00:30:45,202 --> 00:30:47,083
you know, we discussed about certain areas

537
00:30:47,083 --> 00:30:52,058
you know are in a more precarious place
for thermal ablation and in those cases

538
00:30:52,058 --> 00:30:54,731
nanopulse gives us an edge.

539
00:30:54,871 --> 00:30:57,135
There are there are other places where it
really doesn't matter.

540
00:30:57,135 --> 00:31:00,271
And some will say, listen, I want to be
awake for this.

541
00:31:00,271 --> 00:31:01,874
I don't care. I'm not going to sleep.

542
00:31:02,115 --> 00:31:06,272
Or the opposite. So there are many factors
that go into this.

543
00:31:06,378 --> 00:31:08,006
it's a serious conversation.

544
00:31:08,236 --> 00:31:10,126
oftentimes, and I think we discussed this
last time,

545
00:31:10,126 --> 00:31:15,238
oftentimes a doctor will send a patient
for something that they don't exactly

546
00:31:15,238 --> 00:31:17,058
understand because they've never done it.

547
00:31:18,298 --> 00:31:20,939
And the patient comes in expecting one
thing,

548
00:31:21,639 --> 00:31:24,500
but it's not realistically the best thing
for them.

549
00:31:24,960 --> 00:31:30,162
And then I have to, you know, go back and
explain why nanopulse is a better option,

550
00:31:30,582 --> 00:31:33,413
RFA is a better option, or surgery is a
better option,

551
00:31:33,413 --> 00:31:34,933
or none of them are good options for them.

552
00:31:35,535 --> 00:31:37,376
And I've had all of those. Yeah.

553
00:31:37,376 --> 00:31:39,436
sometimes surgery is the right thing to
do.

554
00:31:39,436 --> 00:31:45,258
but the exciting thing for me is that we
have options to discuss with the patient.

555
00:31:45,258 --> 00:31:50,160
I love being able to explain to them why I
think the way I do.

556
00:31:51,260 --> 00:31:53,081
And this is what I recommend. Now,

557
00:31:53,741 --> 00:31:57,623
sometimes, rarely, the patient and I come
to an impasse.

558
00:31:59,144 --> 00:32:00,144
They will say.

559
00:32:00,542 --> 00:32:03,241
I came for this and this is the only thing
I will do.

560
00:32:03,896 --> 00:32:04,896
Right.

561
00:32:05,302 --> 00:32:09,042
And if I in good conscience do not believe
that that's the right thing to do,

562
00:32:09,524 --> 00:32:11,870
I will say very nicely and thank you for
coming in.

563
00:32:12,632 --> 00:32:14,056
I'm not the one who's going to do it for
you.

564
00:32:14,425 --> 00:32:15,392
And that's okay.

565
00:32:15,392 --> 00:32:20,685
It it's absolutely unfair to give someone
something that they want that

566
00:32:20,685 --> 00:32:23,766
you in all good conscience don't believe
is good for them.

567
00:32:23,766 --> 00:32:29,305
Right. And, you know, I have had to
counsel patients who came to me who said,

568
00:32:29,305 --> 00:32:31,421
I really don't want to have my thyroid
taken out.

569
00:32:31,781 --> 00:32:33,582
Is there anything that I can have done?

570
00:32:33,582 --> 00:32:35,633
And when I look at their situation,

571
00:32:35,633 --> 00:32:38,345
I'm like, no I think you really need to
have surgery.

572
00:32:38,345 --> 00:32:40,587
Obviously, I'm not giving you medical
advice.

573
00:32:40,587 --> 00:32:41,587
I'm telling you.

574
00:32:41,587 --> 00:32:45,719
As a lay person, and given the knowledge
that I've acquired over seven years

575
00:32:45,719 --> 00:32:48,971
in this space, I don't know anyone who
would treat you.

576
00:32:49,447 --> 00:32:52,674
And I don't think that anyone would would
think that was responsible.

577
00:32:52,674 --> 00:32:58,138
And that's being honest and forthright and
taking into consideration what's best

578
00:32:58,138 --> 00:32:59,409
for that patient in the long run.

579
00:32:59,409 --> 00:33:01,790
As you said, Hippocrates, first do know
harm,

580
00:33:01,870 --> 00:33:02,528
right?

581
00:33:02,528 --> 00:33:04,339
I don't I don't bully my patients.

582
00:33:04,339 --> 00:33:08,932
I don't bully my patients into surgery and
I don't let them bully me into doing

583
00:33:08,932 --> 00:33:13,684
things that I don't believe are the moral
and ethical and correct thing

584
00:33:13,684 --> 00:33:15,686
to do for them. but you know, that's fine.

585
00:33:15,686 --> 00:33:17,297
I'm I'm comfortable with that.

586
00:33:17,523 --> 00:33:19,225
Yeah, I love the way you put that.

587
00:33:19,226 --> 00:33:22,489
nicely put. Well, Let's go back to
nanopulse

588
00:33:22,814 --> 00:33:27,708
and talking about patients who've had an
RFA and maybe they still have some

589
00:33:27,708 --> 00:33:32,504
residual tissue left. Is nanopulse
possibly an answer for that residual

590
00:33:32,504 --> 00:33:33,504
tissue?

591
00:33:33,758 --> 00:33:34,758
I've done it.

592
00:33:35,239 --> 00:33:35,990
Okay.

593
00:33:35,990 --> 00:33:38,031
I've done it. Yep. Absolutely.

594
00:33:38,592 --> 00:33:40,914
Yep. I've had patients who have out of
RFA.

595
00:33:41,394 --> 00:33:43,176
And like I said, I see them every year.

596
00:33:43,228 --> 00:33:47,229
And after a year, you're not going to get
any meaningful shrinkage from RFA.

597
00:33:47,229 --> 00:33:49,379
About a year's about it. And they say,

598
00:33:49,379 --> 00:33:50,932
How does it look? And I say, you know,

599
00:33:50,932 --> 00:33:52,253
we did this a couple of years ago.

600
00:33:52,253 --> 00:33:53,684
It looks as good as it's gonna get.

601
00:33:54,124 --> 00:33:56,716
Is it bothering you? Yeah, I'm not really
sure.

602
00:33:56,716 --> 00:33:59,799
I don't know. can you make make it any
smaller?

603
00:33:59,799 --> 00:34:01,170
I said, you know, we have something.

604
00:34:01,620 --> 00:34:04,893
That I'd like to try. And I think that
this will give you yeah,

605
00:34:04,893 --> 00:34:08,267
and it works nicely. It works just like it
would on any other thyroid tissue.

606
00:34:08,267 --> 00:34:10,069
It's not like one precludes the other.

607
00:34:10,910 --> 00:34:17,678
Okay, follow up to that. Are you treating
live tissue or dead tissue when

608
00:34:17,678 --> 00:34:21,061
you go back in and you and you are
treating an area that hasn't responded?

609
00:34:21,062 --> 00:34:24,666
The the dead tissue is evacuated by
macrophages.

610
00:34:24,666 --> 00:34:27,719
It's not like the dead tissue just hangs
around.

611
00:34:28,342 --> 00:34:28,962
Okay.

612
00:34:28,962 --> 00:34:34,826
So the shrinkage that you see with thermal
ablation or the shrinkage you see leaves

613
00:34:34,826 --> 00:34:40,259
only live tissue behind. The the dead
tissue is eaten up by macrophages

614
00:34:40,259 --> 00:34:41,320
and removed from the body.

615
00:34:41,573 --> 00:34:45,435
Okay. So you just fun you just
fundamentally changed my understanding

616
00:34:45,435 --> 00:34:46,742
on this because I

617
00:34:46,925 --> 00:34:51,828
for a very long time thought that it would
only shrink to a certain degree and that

618
00:34:51,828 --> 00:34:56,190
what was left in the middle was just a
kind of a dead zone.

619
00:34:56,531 --> 00:34:58,852
So that you're telling me that that's not
a dead zone.

620
00:34:58,753 --> 00:34:59,814
It's not a dead zone.

621
00:35:00,153 --> 00:35:00,876
my goodness.

622
00:35:00,876 --> 00:35:02,759
The dead tissue is evacuated.

623
00:35:03,027 --> 00:35:04,027
Wow. Okay.

624
00:35:04,442 --> 00:35:06,044
That's how the shrinkage occurs.

625
00:35:06,251 --> 00:35:06,985
Mm-hmm.

626
00:35:06,985 --> 00:35:10,340
It would be really bad. It would be really
bad if dead tissue is hanging around

627
00:35:10,340 --> 00:35:11,832
in your body. Right?

628
00:35:12,840 --> 00:35:16,053
that makes sense. I just, for people who
have really,

629
00:35:16,053 --> 00:35:18,285
really massive nodules like myself,

630
00:35:18,285 --> 00:35:20,908
my nodule was between sixty-five and
seventy-five mls.

631
00:35:20,908 --> 00:35:25,431
And I have this residual like six
milliliter.

632
00:35:25,739 --> 00:35:30,991
Piece left. I thought it was just that
everything came in and there was just this

633
00:35:30,991 --> 00:35:36,903
little like, you know, think of it like a
core in a inside of a planet that

634
00:35:36,903 --> 00:35:38,494
was just, you know, remaining.

635
00:35:38,494 --> 00:35:41,148
So you just taught me something new.

636
00:35:41,148 --> 00:35:42,738
man. Thank you for that. All right.

637
00:35:42,738 --> 00:35:47,340
Well, something very interesting now that
I've had my little learning moment.

638
00:35:47,359 --> 00:35:49,861
we've talked about treating nodules,

639
00:35:49,861 --> 00:35:54,245
and there are some doctors who are even
treating primary thyroid cancers with

640
00:35:54,245 --> 00:35:59,149
this. Right. And now I kind of want to go
into this next part with a story because

641
00:35:59,149 --> 00:36:01,051
I do have I I mentioned this earlier,

642
00:36:01,271 --> 00:36:05,735
a patient who shared an experience at last
year's ThyCa conference.

643
00:36:06,489 --> 00:36:09,520
Who was a patient who had a thyroidectomy
many years ago?

644
00:36:10,061 --> 00:36:11,901
She had a thyroid cancer recurrence,

645
00:36:12,001 --> 00:36:16,473
and it was in a location where it simply
could not be removed surgically.

646
00:36:16,473 --> 00:36:21,365
And this doctor treated her with
nanopulse.

647
00:36:21,865 --> 00:36:23,766
She had a pretty good outcome.

648
00:36:23,766 --> 00:36:27,257
And we're just kind of waiting to see how
she's doing.

649
00:36:27,257 --> 00:36:29,228
She's kind of giving us updates from time
to time.

650
00:36:29,768 --> 00:36:34,350
So tell us about this kind of use of
nanopulse.

651
00:36:34,714 --> 00:36:37,285
Well, this the area that I think I'm the
most excited about.

652
00:36:37,685 --> 00:36:44,458
people are being treated for metastatic
thyroid cancer with radio frequency

653
00:36:44,458 --> 00:36:48,650
ablation and with microwave. It it's being
done.

654
00:36:48,650 --> 00:36:52,972
And we're beginning to explore nanopulse
and select patients with recurrent

655
00:36:53,472 --> 00:36:55,753
metastatic thyroid lesions.

656
00:36:56,391 --> 00:36:59,884
particularly when it's locoregional
disease,

657
00:37:00,421 --> 00:37:04,805
or and it's a place where surgery may
cause morbidity,

658
00:37:05,225 --> 00:37:09,629
or it's a very old, frail patient who
would not survive surgery,

659
00:37:09,629 --> 00:37:13,983
or it's their seventh surgery for
recurrence and they say no more surgery.

660
00:37:13,983 --> 00:37:19,697
Yeah. And we know that that lymph node in
and of itself is probably not going

661
00:37:19,697 --> 00:37:22,470
to kill the patient. Right.

662
00:37:22,910 --> 00:37:25,031
Reoperative thyroid surgery, trust me,

663
00:37:25,031 --> 00:37:29,263
can be very challenging. the tissue is
scarred,

664
00:37:29,304 --> 00:37:31,282
and it's near some very important things.

665
00:37:31,282 --> 00:37:32,865
You know, we discussed them before.

666
00:37:33,165 --> 00:37:39,028
so you know, in carefully selected
patients with limited imageable targets,

667
00:37:39,909 --> 00:37:42,410
I think that percutaneous ablation,

668
00:37:43,870 --> 00:37:45,321
as you mentioned, nanopulse.

669
00:37:46,109 --> 00:37:50,680
May offer another very exciting local
control strategy.

670
00:37:51,961 --> 00:37:56,843
I want to emphasize this is not a
replacement for appropriate thyroid cancer

671
00:37:56,843 --> 00:37:58,904
surgery or systemic treatment.

672
00:37:58,944 --> 00:38:02,545
the patient requires a multidisciplinary
evaluation,

673
00:38:02,765 --> 00:38:07,808
careful selection, and the question that
needs to be asked and answered is:

674
00:38:08,248 --> 00:38:10,389
what are we trying to accomplish?

675
00:38:11,131 --> 00:38:14,644
in metastatic disease in this particular
patient.

676
00:38:14,645 --> 00:38:17,268
If you put all those things into context,

677
00:38:17,588 --> 00:38:21,292
then I think that this may be an exciting
alternative that we're going to be seeing

678
00:38:21,292 --> 00:38:24,976
in the next coming years. And I am
thrilled to be part of it.

679
00:38:25,239 --> 00:38:30,480
Very exciting indeed. And for the patients
who are watching this and they're

680
00:38:30,480 --> 00:38:33,001
not familiar with the concept of

681
00:38:33,171 --> 00:38:35,522
treating metastatic lymph nodes.

682
00:38:35,522 --> 00:38:38,473
So in a patient who's already had their
thyroid removed,

683
00:38:38,773 --> 00:38:41,174
they have cancer that comes back in their
lymph nodes.

684
00:38:41,674 --> 00:38:43,954
Typically they would have to go under
surgery again.

685
00:38:44,275 --> 00:38:48,716
So treating these lymph nodes with
ablation allows that patient to avoid,

686
00:38:48,716 --> 00:38:51,146
as you said, surgery five, six,

687
00:38:51,146 --> 00:38:52,146
seven. And

688
00:38:52,461 --> 00:38:53,775
that's exciting for those patients.

689
00:38:53,775 --> 00:38:56,374
They've been through a lot. They don't
want to continue to go through those

690
00:38:56,374 --> 00:38:57,738
surgeries if they can avoid them.

691
00:38:57,978 --> 00:39:03,761
a thyroid cancer is a surgically treated
disease in 2026.

692
00:39:03,761 --> 00:39:05,611
That's the way it is. After that,

693
00:39:05,611 --> 00:39:07,586
we give the patients radioactive iodine,

694
00:39:07,621 --> 00:39:10,142
Some people get it twice, sometimes even
three times.

695
00:39:10,162 --> 00:39:16,273
the cancer when it recurs, oftentimes it
becomes more and more aggressive and less

696
00:39:16,273 --> 00:39:18,534
and less amenable to radioiodine
treatment.

697
00:39:19,146 --> 00:39:21,718
That is the nature of the biology of the
disease.

698
00:39:21,718 --> 00:39:27,923
And sometimes patients will come in
looking for local tumor control.

699
00:39:27,933 --> 00:39:34,238
when trying to eradicate or substantially
control a discrete focus of thyroid cancer

700
00:39:34,438 --> 00:39:40,562
with minimizing morbidity. So success
isn't I cured you,

701
00:39:41,223 --> 00:39:44,095
success is I shrunk this lesion.

702
00:39:44,467 --> 00:39:46,979
by seventy percent. Is

703
00:39:46,335 --> 00:39:46,979
Mm-hmm.

704
00:39:46,979 --> 00:39:48,461
the questions we're asking are,

705
00:39:48,521 --> 00:39:51,243
is there viable tumor left? is it growing?

706
00:39:51,330 --> 00:39:54,382
Is the patient free of progressing
disease?

707
00:39:55,063 --> 00:39:59,986
Those are all oncological endpoints and
they really must be taken in context

708
00:40:00,367 --> 00:40:04,359
together with everything before we embark
on doing this.

709
00:40:04,359 --> 00:40:06,151
But like I said, exciting times.

710
00:40:06,401 --> 00:40:08,353
you you and I have this conversation a
year,

711
00:40:08,353 --> 00:40:11,435
two years from now, you may be very
different answers.

712
00:40:11,595 --> 00:40:12,736
So I look forward to that.

713
00:40:13,590 --> 00:40:15,881
Very, very cool. Exciting. Well,

714
00:40:16,360 --> 00:40:19,442
a couple more questions about this
comparison.

715
00:40:19,567 --> 00:40:24,389
if you have a patient who's not a good
candidate for nanopulse,

716
00:40:24,409 --> 00:40:26,030
what does that conversation look like?

717
00:40:26,285 --> 00:40:29,627
a patient who's not a good candidate for
nanopulse is often a patient who's

718
00:40:29,627 --> 00:40:32,289
not a good candidate for any type of
ablation.

719
00:40:32,289 --> 00:40:35,431
a small benign nodule that's asymptomatic.

720
00:40:35,692 --> 00:40:37,433
I have patients coming in and saying,

721
00:40:37,563 --> 00:40:40,145
I want ablation. And I say, Why?

722
00:40:40,145 --> 00:40:42,276
And the answer is, I don't know,

723
00:40:42,276 --> 00:40:44,167
because I have a nodule. I said,

724
00:40:44,167 --> 00:40:46,579
Is it bothering you? No, I didn't know it
was there.

725
00:40:47,180 --> 00:40:51,462
So why are we doing this? So that's a
really big difference.

726
00:40:52,022 --> 00:40:57,195
Symptomatic patients. And those are
symptoms that I accept as attributable

727
00:40:57,195 --> 00:41:02,698
to the thyroid nodule. Someone comes in
and they have a peripheral half millimeter

728
00:41:02,698 --> 00:41:06,690
thyroid nodule and they're having a lot of
throat clearing and dysphagia,

729
00:41:06,831 --> 00:41:09,492
problems swallowing. I'm not convinced.

730
00:41:10,613 --> 00:41:12,534
And therefore, I will not perform that.

731
00:41:12,534 --> 00:41:13,915
That's not the right thing to do.

732
00:41:14,035 --> 00:41:16,917
They more likely have reflux, which I can
treat with medicine,

733
00:41:17,237 --> 00:41:19,068
and we can watch their thyroid nodule.

734
00:41:19,852 --> 00:41:22,204
There are also other technical
considerations.

735
00:41:22,584 --> 00:41:25,947
Very large lesions with substernal
extension,

736
00:41:25,967 --> 00:41:31,422
areas that are difficult or impossible to
visualize with ultrasound because they're

737
00:41:31,422 --> 00:41:32,419
behind bone,

738
00:41:32,419 --> 00:41:38,288
or a nodule where I cannot confidently
define the treatment margin.

739
00:41:38,525 --> 00:41:41,287
One of the patients I saw today that I
said who's leaving with surgery.

740
00:41:42,453 --> 00:41:44,556
This patient had a huge goiter,

741
00:41:44,556 --> 00:41:46,378
which was substernal and no nodule.

742
00:41:46,378 --> 00:41:48,991
It was just a huge diffuse thyroid.

743
00:41:49,211 --> 00:41:50,893
There was no real target.

744
00:41:51,086 --> 00:41:54,095
so the question isn't, can I just put an
electrode in it?

745
00:41:54,476 --> 00:41:58,701
Question is, is abalation the appropriate
treatment for this patient?

746
00:41:58,701 --> 00:41:59,752
That's the right thing to do.

747
00:42:00,089 --> 00:42:03,771
Yeah, it's a conversation that we have
daily in our community.

748
00:42:03,771 --> 00:42:08,944
And, you know, the most important thing is
that patients understand that it's

749
00:42:08,944 --> 00:42:11,196
individualized. Everyone's different.

750
00:42:11,216 --> 00:42:12,208
Everyone's got,

751
00:42:12,208 --> 00:42:15,530
aside from their own biology to consider,

752
00:42:15,571 --> 00:42:19,273
they've got their own personal values that
they bring to the table.

753
00:42:19,273 --> 00:42:24,267
And so the last question I'll ask about
candidacy is if you've got someone in your

754
00:42:24,267 --> 00:42:25,189
office.

755
00:42:25,189 --> 00:42:27,474
And all of these options are on the table
for them.

756
00:42:28,176 --> 00:42:32,466
How do you help guide them through that
discussion to land on what's the best

757
00:42:32,466 --> 00:42:33,466
outcome for them?

758
00:42:34,694 --> 00:42:35,885
So, we start with the patient,

759
00:42:35,885 --> 00:42:39,067
number one. Number two, then we go to the
disease,

760
00:42:40,248 --> 00:42:43,330
not the device, the disease. Is it benign?

761
00:42:43,650 --> 00:42:45,792
Is it indeterminate? Is it malignant?

762
00:42:45,972 --> 00:42:48,093
Each one of them gets its own answer.

763
00:42:48,093 --> 00:42:51,195
And in most cases, only benign gets
abalation.

764
00:42:51,255 --> 00:42:53,169
Small malignancies I will do as well.

765
00:42:53,297 --> 00:42:57,039
Then the question is: does it actually
need to be treated?

766
00:42:57,339 --> 00:42:58,880
Like what I just said before.

767
00:42:59,024 --> 00:43:00,211
Why are we doing this at all?

768
00:43:00,333 --> 00:43:01,953
Then, third, what is the goal?

769
00:43:02,013 --> 00:43:04,434
symptom relief? Is it cosmetic
improvement?

770
00:43:04,794 --> 00:43:08,592
Is it local cancer control? then we look
at the anatomy,

771
00:43:08,592 --> 00:43:11,062
the size, the composition, the location,

772
00:43:11,202 --> 00:43:13,153
the relationship to critical structures,

773
00:43:13,153 --> 00:43:14,963
all things that you and I have discussed
today.

774
00:43:15,272 --> 00:43:17,713
and then we choose the technology.

775
00:43:18,009 --> 00:43:20,090
if someone comes into the office saying,

776
00:43:20,688 --> 00:43:22,212
I want this,

777
00:43:22,561 --> 00:43:25,584
my job is not to sell them a procedure.

778
00:43:26,485 --> 00:43:31,379
My job is to determine which treatment
makes the most sense for whatever

779
00:43:31,379 --> 00:43:34,411
is ailing them. Sometimes it's RFA,

780
00:43:34,892 --> 00:43:38,014
sometimes it's nanopulse, sometimes it's
surgery,

781
00:43:38,174 --> 00:43:40,036
sometimes it's observation alone.

782
00:43:40,393 --> 00:43:43,454
for patients who are looking to access
this procedure,

783
00:43:43,674 --> 00:43:45,144
which may or may not be for them,

784
00:43:45,144 --> 00:43:48,155
but if they want to know about it and talk
with someone who does it,

785
00:43:48,876 --> 00:43:51,657
let's talk about availability of this in
the US.

786
00:43:51,797 --> 00:43:54,308
You mentioned earlier there's only a few
of you that are doing this

787
00:43:54,308 --> 00:43:58,719
in the physician community. I believe off
the top of my head,

788
00:43:58,840 --> 00:44:00,120
there might be a dozen.

789
00:44:01,058 --> 00:44:02,848
At most, at most. Yeah.

790
00:44:03,600 --> 00:44:08,858
So talk about the adoption of this
technology and compare it kind

791
00:44:08,858 --> 00:44:13,557
of to the pace of the adoption of RFA in
the physician community.

792
00:44:14,243 --> 00:44:19,655
For nanopulse, the technology received FDA
clearance for soft tissue ablation.

793
00:44:19,655 --> 00:44:23,827
The adoption for thyroid applications is
early.

794
00:44:25,063 --> 00:44:26,824
but that's normal for new technology.

795
00:44:26,824 --> 00:44:30,345
That's how new technology is. I think that
RFA,

796
00:44:30,345 --> 00:44:33,236
I mean, you would know RFA went through
the exact same evolution.

797
00:44:33,236 --> 00:44:36,738
Early adopters, development of training
programs,

798
00:44:36,738 --> 00:44:39,799
increasing evidence, society involvement,

799
00:44:39,799 --> 00:44:40,929
broader adoption.

800
00:44:41,540 --> 00:44:44,398
And nanopulse is at the beginning of that
process.

801
00:44:45,071 --> 00:44:49,340
Maybe it will be considerably faster
because people know of RFA.

802
00:44:49,340 --> 00:44:51,946
I don't know. I don't know. But that's
what makes it exciting.

803
00:44:51,946 --> 00:44:54,652
And that's why I love being part of part
of this.

804
00:44:55,152 --> 00:44:57,173
It is exciting. And, as you said,

805
00:44:57,173 --> 00:45:00,514
we've seen the pattern that was started
with RFA.

806
00:45:00,755 --> 00:45:02,106
And now we're seeing it again.

807
00:45:02,106 --> 00:45:03,557
And it's just a different flavor.

808
00:45:03,917 --> 00:45:06,899
So watching it play out has been very
interesting.

809
00:45:07,210 --> 00:45:11,202
but unfortunately, one of the persistent
barriers that we saw with

810
00:45:11,202 --> 00:45:14,724
RFA and now we're seeing with nanopulse is
insurance reimbursement.

811
00:45:14,724 --> 00:45:18,106
And I know you mentioned earlier that that
was its whole own episode.

812
00:45:19,024 --> 00:45:24,402
Can you speak to that just give us a quick
summary of where we're at with that right

813
00:45:24,402 --> 00:45:24,933
now?

814
00:45:24,933 --> 00:45:26,754
all you need to do is look backwards.

815
00:45:26,754 --> 00:45:29,114
It's one of the practical limitations
right now.

816
00:45:29,114 --> 00:45:34,776
Look at RFA. It took years to get more
standardized coding and reimbursement

817
00:45:34,776 --> 00:45:36,456
and fights with insurance companies.

818
00:45:36,456 --> 00:45:39,767
And it's experimental and very frustrated
patients.

819
00:45:39,767 --> 00:45:43,338
Because the the the one that's frustrates
the most is the patients and I,

820
00:45:43,829 --> 00:45:46,880
nanopulse is newer, reimbursement is not
yet mature,

821
00:45:46,880 --> 00:45:50,711
coverage can be sporadic. depends on the
indication.

822
00:45:51,089 --> 00:45:53,241
The insurer, the circumstances,

823
00:45:53,421 --> 00:45:58,155
the part of the state. When when one of my
students who I taught within

824
00:45:58,155 --> 00:46:03,780
the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and I
were doing RFA and she was having a whole

825
00:46:03,780 --> 00:46:05,992
host of insurance issues, and I wasn't,

826
00:46:06,392 --> 00:46:08,714
and I had no clear answer as to why.

827
00:46:08,854 --> 00:46:10,375
And we're in the same Commonwealth.

828
00:46:10,496 --> 00:46:12,637
I don't know why. I do not know why.

829
00:46:13,038 --> 00:46:17,131
Patients need to discuss this directly
with the treatment center because the

830
00:46:17,399 --> 00:46:20,480
The clinical question of can we do it and
the reimbursement question,

831
00:46:20,480 --> 00:46:23,932
will insurance cover it, are unfortunately
not the same question.

832
00:46:24,513 --> 00:46:25,053
Yeah.

833
00:46:25,012 --> 00:46:25,492
Patients

834
00:46:25,492 --> 00:46:29,114
get very, very frustrated. I had a very
angry patient last week.

835
00:46:29,394 --> 00:46:32,155
Why can't you tell the insurance companies
to pay for it?

836
00:46:32,155 --> 00:46:35,017
Not, you know, I I had no good answer for
that.

837
00:46:35,945 --> 00:46:39,636
I honestly, if anyone on this who's
watching this episode follows

838
00:46:39,636 --> 00:46:44,498
me on Instagram, I've been posting some
stuff lately on my stories that it will

839
00:46:44,498 --> 00:46:49,219
infuriate you about how the insurance
companies behave,

840
00:46:49,219 --> 00:46:51,811
but that's that's another conversation.

841
00:46:51,811 --> 00:46:55,142
Okay, well, let's as we round out this
conversation,

842
00:46:55,142 --> 00:46:58,433
let's think about physicians who are
considering adopting this.

843
00:46:58,943 --> 00:47:03,701
say they're already proficient in RFA and
they're intrigued by this new technology.

844
00:47:04,172 --> 00:47:08,590
how significant is the additional training
investment and where do they go to get

845
00:47:09,110 --> 00:47:15,223
you know, if an experienced RFA surgeon
has a substantial head start because

846
00:47:15,223 --> 00:47:18,366
the hardest skills they're not device
specific.

847
00:47:18,366 --> 00:47:19,876
Like we said at the very beginning,

848
00:47:19,936 --> 00:47:22,387
if you look from the outside, it would
look i identical.

849
00:47:22,397 --> 00:47:25,088
you know, I still advocate for structured
training.

850
00:47:25,098 --> 00:47:28,699
different energy sources may behave a
little bit differently.

851
00:47:28,934 --> 00:47:32,120
guess the electrogeometry, the treatment
zone dimensions,

852
00:47:32,120 --> 00:47:34,544
overlap, how you overlap treatment areas,

853
00:47:34,837 --> 00:47:37,209
I I guess those things matter to a certain
degree.

854
00:47:37,209 --> 00:47:42,903
Becoming an expert may not make you an
expert in the in the new technology.

855
00:47:43,644 --> 00:47:46,506
from my transition, not a transition
because I do both.

856
00:47:46,887 --> 00:47:51,991
It was not, it really was not a hard
conversion at all.

857
00:47:52,388 --> 00:47:54,019
Where do people go to get trained?

858
00:47:54,245 --> 00:47:56,195
I don't know. I we do an RFA course,

859
00:47:56,526 --> 00:47:58,616
thyroid ablation course every year in
Hershey,

860
00:47:58,616 --> 00:48:01,387
Pennsylvania. This will be our fifth or
sixth year.

861
00:48:01,387 --> 00:48:03,907
we do courses down in Rio de Janeiro very
often.

862
00:48:03,907 --> 00:48:09,189
We have one in December. I would think
that if someone wanted to do nanopulse

863
00:48:09,189 --> 00:48:13,250
and couldn't find a specific course for
nanopulse,

864
00:48:13,570 --> 00:48:15,841
an RFA course would do the trick for them.

865
00:48:15,841 --> 00:48:18,732
I really do. And those of us who are doing
it.

866
00:48:19,404 --> 00:48:22,570
are usually very happy to train proctor,

867
00:48:23,253 --> 00:48:26,499
come and watch a few or I should come out
to you and watch you do a few.

868
00:48:27,121 --> 00:48:28,383
that's usually how it's taught.

869
00:48:29,039 --> 00:48:33,252
Well, one last question for a patient
who's watching this and they're interested

870
00:48:33,252 --> 00:48:36,665
in learning about if they may be a
candidate for nanopulse,

871
00:48:37,525 --> 00:48:41,729
what would you say is the most important
thing that they should know going into

872
00:48:41,729 --> 00:48:43,410
that conversation with their physician?

873
00:48:45,100 --> 00:48:48,312
Like I said before, you don't go in
saying,

874
00:48:48,890 --> 00:48:53,906
I want a certain technology. It's like
someone coming to me for surgery and say,

875
00:48:53,906 --> 00:48:55,307
I want you cutting with this knife,

876
00:48:55,307 --> 00:48:56,458
but not that scissors.

877
00:48:58,104 --> 00:48:58,399
Yeah.

878
00:48:58,399 --> 00:49:02,817
Yes, it's very similar. and I don't think
most people would say that were for their

879
00:49:02,817 --> 00:49:05,940
surgeon. Certainly in my over 25 years,

880
00:49:05,940 --> 00:49:09,171
no one's ever asked me that. I would start
by getting a diagnosis,

881
00:49:09,432 --> 00:49:12,334
making sure the treatment decision is
right for you.

882
00:49:12,854 --> 00:49:17,097
there's only a dozen of us, but those who
are doing nanopulse are also doing RFA.

883
00:49:17,138 --> 00:49:19,899
and so I would talk to someone who
understands the full spectrum,

884
00:49:20,620 --> 00:49:23,222
observation, surgery, minimally invasive
techniques,

885
00:49:23,222 --> 00:49:25,383
whichever they may be. and then,

886
00:49:25,443 --> 00:49:27,304
you know, if nanopulse is right,

887
00:49:27,304 --> 00:49:28,725
then I would I would say, you know,

888
00:49:28,725 --> 00:49:30,686
why are we doing this, that, or the other
thing?

889
00:49:30,686 --> 00:49:31,686
And what are your

890
00:49:31,845 --> 00:49:33,135
as you as a treating physician,

891
00:49:34,036 --> 00:49:36,417
what is your thought process for saying
RFA?

892
00:49:36,417 --> 00:49:40,438
And if I say to you, listen, this is
purely cystic nodule and the results will

893
00:49:40,438 --> 00:49:43,729
be better with RFA than if you trust me,

894
00:49:43,729 --> 00:49:45,600
you'll do it the way I recommend it.

895
00:49:45,600 --> 00:49:48,511
so that that's the way I think a patient
should ask the question.

896
00:49:48,511 --> 00:49:50,562
First, you know, why am I having this
done?

897
00:49:50,562 --> 00:49:51,922
And that's not like I said before,

898
00:49:51,922 --> 00:49:54,553
it's not a given. I mean patients
sometimes are

899
00:49:55,097 --> 00:49:57,978
chasing a technology. but you know,

900
00:49:57,978 --> 00:50:01,292
that's that's part of our job as
physicians is to kind of teach them

901
00:50:01,413 --> 00:50:04,613
and explain to them so that they can make
educated decisions.

902
00:50:05,689 --> 00:50:09,925
100% agree. Dr. Goldenberg, it's been a
pleasure chatting with you today.

903
00:50:10,145 --> 00:50:14,991
Anyone who wants to reach out to you for
any of the options that you offer,

904
00:50:15,393 --> 00:50:16,594
tell us how you can do that.

905
00:50:16,816 --> 00:50:21,859
So you can get more information on Penn
State Health Radio Frequency Ablation

906
00:50:21,859 --> 00:50:24,267
or Nanopulse Ablation. reach

907
00:50:24,267 --> 00:50:30,531
out to 717-531-6822

908
00:50:30,531 --> 00:50:31,767
and ask about

909
00:50:31,887 --> 00:50:36,496
minimally invasive thyroid treatment or
thyroid ablation and someone will

910
00:50:37,379 --> 00:50:39,503
get you to my people.

911
00:50:40,701 --> 00:50:43,046
Perfect. Well, it's been a pleasure
talking with you today,

912
00:50:43,046 --> 00:50:48,508
Dr. Goldenberg I can't wait to see where
this leads and hear what you learned

913
00:50:48,508 --> 00:50:51,234
the next year or two after you've used
this technology.

 

Related to this Episode

Nanopulse or RFA for Thyroid Nodules? A Surgeon Who Does Both Explains | Dr. David Goldenberg

SAVE YOUR THYROID with Jennifer Holkem, episode 132 For years, one of the most common messages I’ve gotten from this community goes something like this: “I was told I’m not a candidate for RFA because my nodule is too close to the nerve.” Those pat…